March 2011
M T W T F S S
« Feb   Apr »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

Can Pharma Save Dr. Lisa Cuddy?

Maybe you read the other day in The New York Times that the pharmaceutical industry has a problem. Big blockbuster drugs like Lipitor are going off patent and the industry leaders don’t have new blockbusters showing promise to replace them. So the big companies search for little companies with new discoveries and they consider buying them. Industry observers think the days of $5 billion- a-year drugs to lower cholesterol or control diabetes may be past for a while, and the companies will have smaller hits with new compounds for autoimmune conditions and cancer.

Dr. Lisa Cuddy on House, M.D.

Dr. Lisa Cuddy on "House, M.D."

When I saw my oncologist for a checkup yesterday – the news was good – we chatted about the article and the trend toward “niche science.” We welcomed it. We didn’t think – from our perspective – the world needed yet another drug to lower cholesterol. We need unique products to fight illnesses that remain daunting, some where there are no effective drugs at all. For example, my daughter has suffered for years from what seems to be an autoimmune condition called eosinophilic gastroenteritis (EGID). Her stomach gets inflamed with her own eosinophil cells. They would normally be marshaled to fight a parasite in her GI tract but in this case, there’s nothing to attack. So the cells make trouble on the lining of the stomach and cause pain and scarring. Right now, there’s no “magic bullet” to turn off these cells. My hope is some pharma scientists will come up with something to fill this unmet need.

In the waiting room before I saw my doctor at the cancer center in Seattle I overheard a woman on the phone speaking about her husband’s new diagnosis of pancreatic cancer. I was sitting at a patient education computer station nearby. When she was finished I introduced myself and showed her some web pages to give her education and hope: pancan.org and our Patient Power programs about the disease. She was grateful.  I did tell her – and she already knew – that there was no miracle drug for pancreatic cancer and that it was a usually fatal condition. But that there were exceptions and, hopefully, her husband would be one. Of course, wouldn’t an effective medicine be best?

Last night I thought of another situation waiting for new pharma science:  I was watching one of my favorite television shows: House M.D.  You know the one where the world’s greatest diagnostician, Dr. Gregory House (Hugh Laurie) says the most inappropriate things. This season, though, we see a bit of a kinder,  gentler side as his love has finally blossomed with his boss, chief medical center doctor Lisa Cuddy (Lisa Edelstein).  Last night the writers gave us – and House – a major whammo: Dr. Cuddy has cancer. First it was a mass in her kidney and it turned out to be renal cell carcinoma. We’ve done programs on that so I know it pretty well.  Then came news that was even worse: a scan showed the cancer had spread to several places in her lungs. The episode ended with House hearing that news and muttering “she’s dead.”

Oh, if only pharma would have a magic bullet for Lisa Cuddy, or the husband with pancreatic cancer, or my daughter. On next week’s House we’ll find out if some clinical trial might give hope for Dr. Cuddy. Certainly anyone with pancreatic cancer or EGID is on the lookout for the same.

Having recently had dinner with some scientists at a pharma company I know they are really working hard for a medical breakthrough. While investors might keep their fingers crossed for a pill that millions could take for years, I know many people where a targeted medicine for their less common cancer or debilitating inflammation would be an answer to their prayers.

I welcome your comments.

Wishing you and your family the best of health!

Andrew

3 comments to Can Pharma Save Dr. Lisa Cuddy?

  • Andrew Holtz

    You might be interested to know that the intersection between the stories on House and the real world of health care is explored in a couple of books. “The Medical Science of House, M.D.” came out in 2006 when the series was young. A follow-up, “House, M.D. vs. Reality” was just released last week.
    http://astore.amazon.com/holtzreport-20

  • Andrew Schorr

    OMG! Esther reminded me that I hadn’t seen the last segtment of the episode. I fell asleep. My apologies to Dr. Cuddy. YOU DON’T HAVE CANCER! It was a non malignant tumor and the spots on your lung were a reaction to an antibiotic. Where do the consulting doctors come up wioth this stuff!

    Anyway, she doesn’t need pharma’s help anymore – even though many of the rest of us do. However, she does need a new boyfriend as House went back to his addiction to pain killers to cope with the stress of what seemed like Cuddy’s terminal illness. Cuddy gave him and their relationship the heave ho. So my next blog should be about the stress of serious illness on caregivers and relationships. Please forgive me for falling asleep on the job! But I think the bottom line of the blog above is still very valid.

  • Kelly

    Andrew,
    I am a 40 year old female physician who was diagnosed with eosinophilic gastroenteritis 2 years ago. I have seen the allergy and GI specialists at CCED in Cincinnati and have tried a variety of therapies with varied success. Nothing that has licked this condition. I came upon your blog while scouring the internet for personal accounts/experiences of this disease. I would love to talk further with you about what therapies have/haven’t worked for your daughter.
    Best,
    Kelly

Leave a Reply

  

  

  


*

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>